Quiet Speculation: Lessons from the Grand Prix

May 27, 2010 by: Kelly Reid

I’m sitting in the airport on the way back from Grand Prix: DC, and my headphones just died as they announced my flight would be delayed by two hours.  Clearly, Johnny Rungood is dead.  Life got the Blightning, Bloodbraid Elf, Cascade into Blightning draw on me today, it would seem.  Nonetheless, that means I have some time to tickle the digital ivories a bit and get my thoughts on the weekend to my MTGO playing readers.

The first thing I noticed is how fast everything evolved this weekend.  Coming in to the tournament, Jund was a big underdog, and that’s just where I wanted to be.  No one was gunning for the Big Green Menace, and it appeared that Mythic was the Deck Du Jour.  Thus, Jund was my deck of choice.

I started by looking at the most effective decks in Standard over the last few weeks, and one thing became clear; Lotus Cobra fit perfectly into my deck.  Once I realized that the majority of the field would not be as scared of Blightning as before, I was happy to cut them from my 75 entirely.  That’s right.  Not a single copy.  The new Jund decks have to keep board parity with the other turbocharged Green decks like Naya and Mythic, so anything that didn’t directly help me gain board parity was not included in my list.  This, I think, is the main reason I made Day 2.  It’s not like I tested for hours or got a lot of sleep (two things I really preach, but given the last-minute nature of this event, did not have the luxury of practicing).

I’m intentionally omitting my list because I want to talk about that in another piece, and instead talk about the format as a whole.  Discussion of Jund is an article unto itself.  It seems that this format has become very polarized again, but not on the axis of archetype.  We have a true Combo-Control-Aggro metagame, even if people don’t realize it.  The Polymorph Combo decks are real, people.   I lost to one on Day 2, and it was simply Red-Blue.  I’ll see if i can find a list, but right now, all you need to know is that he killed me in response to Bloodbraid Elf by shooting my face with spawning breath, untapping, and Emrakul’ing me out of the game.  Lost that one, folks.

The Control decks come in the Planeswalker-heavy variety, the Tap-Out style UW decks (which just seem worse than PWs), and the Chapin-style draw-go UW decks.  All have their place, and I anticipate we will see them merging into one archetype before the season is over.

Aggro decks are almost all Green-centric, as they ought to be.  You’d need to be crazy or stupid to not include Bloodbraid Elf in your Aggro decks (unless you play Mythic, in which case, you’re both).  Lotus Cobra works so much better with Aggro than many think, and I am sure we have not even come CLOSE to optimizing our decks for our serpentine buddy.  Vengevine is out right unfair, especially with Lotus Cobra and Bloodbraid Elf assisting in the rebuy process.  The amount of value that those three cards generate off eachother is quite unfair, and I cannot see playing a beatdown deck without all 3.

In my opinion, the Red/Green decks are probably the way to go with Beatdown.  Your choice of splash color – White or Black – is really the only discussion at hand.  White gives you access to worse removal (Path is totally elite, but Doom Blade and Terminate are often better) but far better creatures overalll.  Black gives you access to the Suicide-Black style Putrid Leech and Sarkhan the Mad, who can do very good things.  I have not decided which archetype I prefer, but I will be tinkering with them over the next few weeks.  I just know that there’s no way I’m not playing beatdown in this format.

Cards to monitor on MTGO include:

Lotus Cobra – He’s much, much better than you think.  The initial hype was probably warranted, and the drop-off was, too.  Once Alara Block rotates, we can really see what this guy can do.  Look to the upcoming Pro Tour to get a glimpse of what New Standard will look like in the fall.

Sarkhan the Mad – At time of writing, he’s still very cheap.  He is instrumental in many Jund builds today, and his unique set of abilities makes him a very powerful tool indeed.  You’re only going to see more lists including the mad shaman of Jund.

Vengevine – Sadly, this doubled on MTGO right around the time I said to keep an eye on it, so this news is less timely than I’d like.  That being said, I believe he was an outright mistake at Mythic, and I do hope R&D give careful consideration to how they choose their rarities from now on.  I don’t like this card at Mythic one bit.  It’s totally unfair, and his little brother Lotus Cobra combos with fetch lands to ensure that you always have free mana to rebuy the Vine.  A format staple for a long time to come.

Sarkhan Vol – Man, does this guy get around or what?  Pre-insanity Sarkhan has the pedegree of a top-tier rare (just check historical prices from his release time), but he did what many top prospects do and flare out.  Naya decks are sideboarding him against blue-based decks, and while I have not seen this in action, I have multiple reports confirming it.  Could be a sick value play on a long out of print Mythic.

Sarkhan Vol is the only Alara-Block card I can really recommend right now.  Historically speaking, late May & early June marks the time when the soon-to-rotate set begins its slow decline, losing approximately half its overall value.  There is a very tangible tipping point that occurs, so if you have a large stock of Shards cards, I would begin the process.  Things like Noble Hierarch and Knight of the Reliquary will hold some value, but as all things do when they rotate, they will probably dip too far, too quickly.  Oddly enough, most of Conflux will retain long-term value since the cards are timeless and versatile.  Progenitus should be an interesting case, as Emrakul seems to have totally usurped the Soul of the World.  Progenitus is the world’s baddest Hydra Avatar, but Emmy is the baddest of asses among an entire race of ancient malevolent old badass gods.  Sorry Progenitus, you’re out-tentacled here.

Overall, I expect to see a slow creep in Zendikar-block Mythics as they become the gold (bronze-ish?) standard of the new format.  The changes will be slow, likely over a few months, but the MTGO market moves much faster than the paper one does.  It’s also a great leading indicator for those who speculate on paper, so it would behoove you to do both if you do one but not  the other.  Hope you enjoyed this bonus article!  Set reviews are often necessary but can be so dry and repetitive.  Get to a Grand Prix whenever you can; this was the most fun I’ve had playing Magic in, quite literally, years.

See you guys in a few!

KBR

 

You may also like...
More expert predictions in the world of Magic economy from Quiet Speculation's own Kelly Reid. Check out some of the surges in a few unexpected cards in the midst of PTQ Season.
Check it Out!
With a new set comes new speculations from our resident MtGO economist Kelly Reid. Read more to find out what you should be buying and for how much.
Check it Out!
Kelly looks at the better performing Extended decks from PT Amsterdam and Scars of Mirrodin's spoiled goodies through the lens of an investor.
Check it Out!
Kelly lays down his giant $ decorated burglar bags to talk about format profitability. This is quick run through of how to get what foot and/or feet wet and where.
Check it Out!
Part Deux of Kelly's machine gun fire buys and don't bothers of the latest set on the shelves and snaking through the wires of MTGO. Tune in, wallet ready, for a more tricks on trading.
Check it Out!
Hot on the tails of Pro Tour San Diego, Kelly examines some of the decks that came out on top and some surprise price fluctuations to expect in the immediate future.
Check it Out!
Kelly once again provides valuable information about the Magic economy. He elaborates on card prices in context of the new set and the upcoming Pro Tour season. Check it out!
Check it Out!
Kelly returns to Extended to discuss the possible sleepers of Shadowmoor (and Lorwyn). Looking to make some money? Read this for ideas.
Check it Out!
Kelly evaluates potential profits to be made off the release of Worldwake online.
Check it Out!
More money-making schemes, spreadsheets, laundered funds, and financial gossip from the one, the only Kelly Reid. Read more... for serious.
Check it Out!
Quiet Speculation: PTQ Part Deux!
Quiet Speculation: 2011 Core Set Hotness!
Quiet Speculation: The Tumultuous Future of Extended
Quiet Speculation: So Many Ways to Play!
Quiet Speculation: Rise of the Eldrazi Prerelease Pricing
Quiet Speculation: Pro Tour Profiteering
Quiet Speculation: PTQ and You
Quiet Speculation: Extended, Lorwyn and Shadowmoor Block
Quiet Speculation: In the Wake of Worldwake
Blast from the Past – Quiet Speculation: Doubling

Comments

6 Responses to “Quiet Speculation: Lessons from the Grand Prix”
  1. SaiDes says:

    Good article, I agree about Vengevine being almost unfair, the thing has spiked in price so much it’s almost at Jace levels in some peoples lists.
    Hopefully we’ll see some interesting things with Lotus Cobra soon as I think it’s definately a card that has room to grow.

    Academy_Points
  2. Jeph Foster says:

    “You’d need to be crazy or stupid to not include Bloodbraid Elf in your Aggro decks (unless you play Mythic, in which case, you’re both)”

    Just so you know, Kelly, I take offense to this statement.

    Academy_Points
  3. Wyrath says:

    Progenitus will still be used in Natural Order decks, so I doubt it’s going to flop too badly.

    I don’t have access to MTGO at the moment (as my laptop recently commited suicide), but if I had, I too would be picking up Sarkhan the Mad. I don’t even care about Standard at all, but it just seems like a wildly underpriced card (same is true with Abyssal Persecutor, which is admittedly, rising a bit in price recently).

  4. Jeph Foster says:

    Wyrath – Progenitus will likely also still be used in Dream Halls, since Emrakul can’t be played off the enchantment.

    Academy_Points
  5. Zage says:

    Your discussion of the decks in Standard is a bit *too* short in my opinion, and didn’t really serve a purpose that abridged. That’s just my opinion of course, but I would prefer to hear about a few decks just a little more than such a broad perspective. But I suppose it was meant more as an introduction.

    I’m disappointed with the lottery/jackpot style of opening boosters you have now. You either high-five all your friends after cracking a pack worth ~50 bucks, or you silently curse your luck for getting a 1 buck mythic, or 50 cent rare. I don’t crack boosters to get a gambling fix :(

    Academy_Points
  6. Aznsilly says:

    what do you think about the fetchlands, will they go up at all after M10 rotates out? even assuming they just stay the same, is it worth it to pick up a set of each? i am pretty new to mtgo and I don’t know why certain fetchlands are so much cheaper than others (namely misty rainforest vs arid mesa) when rainforest is probably more used.

    Academy_Points

Leave a Reply

Spam protection by WP Captcha-Free