Forcing the Will: Baneslayer Control

Hello and welcome fellow readers to another edition of Forcing the Will! Finally it’s here, the deck that so many of my readers have been waiting for- the Baneslayer Control deck to be exact! I will cover the deck along with some changes that I made as well as providing video of the deck against some of the best players in the MTGO Legacy format. But before we do that, let’s take a look at the Legacy metagame.

Legacy Metagame

8/31/2010 (Event #1529869)

  • (4-0) Show and Tell
  • (4-0) Rb Goblins
  • (3-1) Imperial Painter
  • (3-1) UBGW Landstill
  • (3-1) Dredge
  • (3-1) Merfolk

9/2/2010 (Event #1554800)

  • (4-0) Imperial Painter
  • (4-0) UBGW Landstill
  • (3-1) Enchantress
  • (3-1) Rb Goblins
  • (3-1) Death and Taxes (DnT)
  • (3-1) New Horizon

9/2/2010 (Event #1554801)

  • (4-0) Death and Taxes (DnT)
  • (4-0) Rg Goblins
  • (3-1) Deadguy Ale
  • (3-1) Red Deck Wins (RDW)
  • (3-1) Death and Taxes (DnT)

9/3/2010 (Event #1554830)

  • (4-0) Enchantress
  • (3-1) Deadguy Ale
  • (3-1) Death and Taxes (DnT)
  • (3-1) Imperial Painter
  • (3-1) Death and Taxes (DnT)

9/4/2010 (Event #1554893)

  • (4-0) Enchantress
  • (3-1) UGr Thresh
  • (3-1) Zoo
  • (3-1) Deadguy Ale
  • (3-1) Merfolk

9/6/2010 (Event #1554874)

  • (4-0) Ad Nauseam Tendrils (ANT)
  • (3-1) Survival Rock (Red Splash)
  • (3-1) Death and Taxes (DnT)
  • (3-1) Hive Mind
  • (3-1) Deadguy Ale
  • (3-1) UBGW Landstill
  • (3-1) Zoo

9/7/2010 (Event #1554907)

  • (4-0) UBG Control
  • (3-1) Death and Taxes (DnT)
  • (3-1) Death and Taxes (DnT)
  • (3-1) Merfolk
  • (3-1) Red Deck Wins (RDW)
  • (3-1) Dredge

9/9/2010 (Event #1579916)

  • (4-0) UBG Control
  • (3-1) UBGW Landstill
  • (3-1) Show and Tell/Hypergenesis
  • (3-1) Death and Taxes (DnT)
  • (3-1) New Horizon

9/9/2010 (Event #1579937)

  • (4-0) Countertop/Thopter
  • (3-1) Merfolk
  • (3-1) Zoo
  • (3-1) Countertop
  • (3-1) Zoo
  • (3-1) Dredge
  • (3-1) UBGW Landstill

9/10/2010 (Event #1579947)

  • (4-0) Dredge
  • (3-1) UBG Control
  • (3-1) Death and Taxes (DnT)
  • (3-1) Rb Goblins
  • (3-1) New Horizon

9/11/2010 (Event #1579966)

  • (4-0) Death and Taxes (DnT)
  • (3-1) Death and Taxes (DnT)
  • (3-1) Ad Nauseam Tendrils (ANT)
  • (3-1) Merfolk
  • (3-1) Show and Tell/Hypergenesis

9/12/2010 (Event #1579981)

  • (4-0) Show and Tell
  • (3-1) Red Deck Wins (RDW)
  • (3-1) New Horizon
  • (3-1) Rb Goblins
  • (3-1) Rb Goblins

Top Legacy Decks Breakdown »

DECK

WINS

PERCENTAGE OF WINS

1. Death and Taxes (DnT)

11

20.37%

2. Goblins

5

9.26%

3. Landstill

5

9.26%

4. Merfolk

5

9.26%

5. Deadguy Ale

4

7.41%

6. Dredge

4

7.41%

7. New Horizon

4

7.41%

8. Show and Tell

4

7.41%

9. Zoo

4

7.41%

10. Enchantress

3

5.56%

11. Imperial Painter

3

5.56%

12. Red Deck Wins (RDW)

3

5.56%

13. UBG Control

3

5.56%

14. Ad Nauseam Tendrils (ANT)

2

3.70%

15. Countertop

1

1.85%

16. Countertop/Thopter

1

1.85%

17. Hive Mind

1

1.85%

18. Survival

1

1.85%

19. Thresh

1

1.85%

TOTAL:

54


Death and Taxes (DnT) is once again supreme, and this week the deck has a clear lead over any other deck in the format. The deck has picked up popularity and with the majority of the deck being relatively cheap, I would highly suggest those looking to get into the Legacy format to pick up the deck and give it a try. In 2nd place, we have Goblins taking a huge jump from the number 13 spot 2 weeks ago. I was rather surprised to see Goblins taking the jump, but as I looked over the list I noticed the majority of the top decks were aggro based decks. With the format rampant with aggro, Goblins can hold their own against other hordes of non-tribal creatures. In the 3rd spot, Landstill once again makes a comeback, and for good reason. As I mention earlier the top decks are mostly aggro based, and anyone who has any experience with the Landstill deck can tell you how good the deck fairs against most aggro decks. I foresee Landstill and Dredge decks being a good choice against these aggro decks in the weeks to come, but remember to be prepared for those combo and control decks as well.

Baneslayer Control

Here it is the deck that so many of my readers have been waiting for- Baneslayer Control! This deck made a surprise appearance in the Bazaar of Moxen IV tournament a few months ago, and when I heard that a deck running not 1, 2, 3, but 4 Baneslayer Angels in Legacy placed 7th in the tournament, I was rather surprised. I never really pictured Baneslayer Angel being a relevant card in the format, but after hearing about this performance I decided to take a closer look at the deck. After looking over the decklist for some time, I was reminded of an old blue-white control deck that used to be played in Standard and Extended back in the day. I quickly built the deck and headed into the Tournament Practice room, and much to my surprise, the deck was slaughtering my opponents left and right! At first, I thought it was just coincident or that my opponents were playing bad decks, but the more I played the deck the more I began to realize the deck has potential in the Legacy format. I made a few changes to the deck, but before I cover that let’s take a look at the original deck.

Similar to the old blue-white control decks the Baneslayer Control deck is a deck that focuses on surviving the early game with countermagic and removal so that the deck can overrun an opponent in the late game. The basic strategy of this deck is to delay your opponent from playing threats by countering their spells, destroying their creatures, or discarding part of their hands. Once you have effectively stopped an opponent and have enough mana, you can cast one of your win conditions, such as Baneslayer Angel, Jace, the Mind Sculptor, and even Glen Elendra Archmage. Now let’s take a look at the additions I made to the deck.

Here is the version of the deck that I chose to run.

You’ll notice that the deck is almost identical with the exception of 1 additional Jace, the Mind Sculptor and 1 Elspeth, Knight-Errant. With the addition of these cards, I took out 1 Glen Elendra Archmage and 1 Engineered Explosives. The reasoning behind this was that the removed cards were not proving to be necessary in most scenarios, and the Planeswalkers were a lot more useful in every game- providing additional win conditions. But if I were to play deck again, I would add an additional Elspeth, Knight-Errant and remove the last Glen Elendra Archmage. Since the decks are so very similar, I will go over the list card-by- card in my Deck Tech video.

Without further ado, I present to you Baneslayer Control in action!

Baneslayer Control Deck Tech

Show Decktech »

You need to install or upgrade Flash Player to view this content, install or upgrade by clicking here.

Legacy Daily Event Round 1

Show Match 1 »

You need to install or upgrade Flash Player to view this content, install or upgrade by clicking here.

Legacy Daily Event Round 2

Show Match 2 »

You need to install or upgrade Flash Player to view this content, install or upgrade by clicking here.

Legacy Daily Event Round 3

Show Match 3 »

You need to install or upgrade Flash Player to view this content, install or upgrade by clicking here.

Legacy Daily Event Round 4

Show Match 4 »

You need to install or upgrade Flash Player to view this content, install or upgrade by clicking here.

I hope you all enjoyed the videos and found them both useful and insightful on the wonderful Baneslayer Control deck. If you have any questions, comments, criticisms, or insight about the deck please feel free to leave a post or message me directly. As always, I appreciate players pointing out mistakes I may not have picked up while playing the deck. I am aware that I forgot to add Perish into my main deck in Round 4, but luckily it didn’t hinder my game plan!

You Choose the Deck!

#1. Ad Nauseam Tendrils (ANT)

#2. Deadguy Ale

#3. Dredge

#4. New Horizon

#5. Aggro Loam

#6. Show and Tell

#7. Goblins

Be sure to post either the deck number or the name of the deck in the comment section. You can also send me a message on the boards or online at KillerOwen. Please make sure to log in to cast your vote as I will ignore anonymous votes. Make sure to get your votes in fast, as I will only allow 2-3 days before choosing the winning deck to cover in my next article. Also note if there is a specific version of a deck you would like to see, and if possible include a link.

That’s all for this article. Thanks for taking the time to read my article and watch my videos. As always please leave any comments, questions, or requests you have good or bad, and I will do my best to respond to them, and until next time may the Force of Will be with you!

Owen Robbins

 
  1. Round 1: I think at the end he’s saying something like “you’re a lucky SOB” but wait for someone who actually speaks the language to confirm or deny it :)

  2. Not so much useful as entertaining. You’re personality and level of play is pretty funny.

    Keep up the vids.

  3. M3G2: you played PtE on the Joutun Grunt instead of Flickerwisp. Grunt was going to dye anyway next turn due to lack of cards in the graveyard

  4. Nice- Shame BSA went only 2-2. Seems like a 3-1 deck.
    Funny how butthurt your 1st opponent was. I dont think he got the memo that BSA is a good card in Legacy =D

    I guess Show and Tell or New Horizons since I have no Idea what that deck is.

  5. So far this is the results:

    ANT 4
    Show and Tell 4
    Deadguy Ale 3
    New Horizon 1

    I will be making a new change to only vote for 1 deck from now on just to make it a bit easier for me. This includes a couple of votes from users who left me a message online. I’ll be taking votes until tomorrow night so make sure to get your votes in!

    @ Kuriboh – I don’t know what he was saying, but at the very end of the game he typed in English so I knew what he was saying then. I don’t even bother looking into those kinds of things, but if someone wanted to do it go ahead.

    @ Mudkips – At least I am providing some entertainment for you glad you enjoy the vids! :D

    @ gopro – The deck is very good, but sometimes your deck just can’t pull through. It’s just part of the game. I had a lot of fun with the deck it’s a very different play style than what I’m normally used to.

    Thanks again for all the comments and support I appreciate everyone taking the time to read and watch my videos! :D

    @ Fragoel2 – I didn’t even notice that. That’s what happens when you rush your plays something I am guilty of quite often :S.

    @ eXXa – I looked back at the match and didn’t really see any opportunities to use the Karakas except if I would of played my Arch Mage, but I decided not to. If there was something else please let me know as I just skimmed through the video.

  6. I’ll be different, i vote Aggro Loam. Never thought i’d see a 4 of with BSA in legacy, cool vids.

  7. ANT 4
    Show and Tell 4
    Deadguy Ale 3
    Aggro Loam 1
    New Horizon 1

    Voting closes tonight. Let’s get some more votes in and break the tie yeah!

  8. Just wanted everyone to know we have a deck that won. You’ll have to wait till my next article to find out which one it is :D.